Home Insurance News Liberty Mutual and Travelers Settle Insurance Dispute Over Elevator Shaft Injury Case

Liberty Mutual and Travelers Settle Insurance Dispute Over Elevator Shaft Injury Case

This case underscores the critical importance of clear indemnity clauses and proper liability insurance documentation in construction projects.

694
0
Liberty Mutual Travelers Insurance Injury Case

[Connecticut, USA] — In a significant development involving a high-stakes liability insurance dispute, Liberty Mutual Insurance announced it has reached a settlement agreement with Travelers Insurance over a lawsuit related to a serious elevator shaft injury on a New York City construction site. The notice of settlement was officially filed in federal court in Connecticut on May 28, 2025.

According to the court filing, Liberty Mutual expects to finalize the settlement within 60 days, after which it plans to dismiss its legal action against Travelers and its affiliated companies.

Construction Site Incident Leads to Injury and Lawsuit

The dispute stems from an incident that occurred during a renovation project commissioned by the City of New York on a facility used by NYU Hospital. The general contractor, Suffolk Construction Co., Inc., had subcontracted a portion of the work to Maccarone Plumbing, Inc.

On March 12, 2020, two plumbers from Maccarone allegedly asked Oscar Marin, a facilities engineer employed by NYU Hospital, to open a disused elevator shaft door in the subbasement. When Marin complied, he fell into the elevator shaft, sustaining serious injuries.

As a result, Marin filed a personal injury lawsuit on February 24, 2021, naming both Suffolk Construction and Maccarone Plumbing as defendants.

Liberty Mutual Assumes Defense of Suffolk Construction

At the time of the incident, Suffolk was insured by Liberty Mutual under a Commercial General Liability (CGL) policy. Upon receiving the complaint, Suffolk requested defense and indemnification coverage from Liberty Mutual, which agreed to defend and indemnify Suffolk as per the policy terms.

According to Liberty Mutual’s court filings, by the time it filed suit against Travelers on February 27, 2025, it had already spent more than $75,000 on Suffolk’s legal defense related to the Marin case.

Also Read: Former West Virginia Fire Official Sentenced to 33 Months for Insurance Fraud and Credit Card Misuse

Liberty Mutual Argues Travelers Should Provide Coverage

Liberty Mutual’s lawsuit claimed that Travelers Insurance was obligated to assume Suffolk’s defense and indemnification responsibilities under policies issued to Maccarone Plumbing, Suffolk’s subcontractor. The claim is rooted in a subcontract agreement between Suffolk and Maccarone, in which Maccarone explicitly agreed to:

“Defend, indemnify, and save harmless Suffolk”
— unless the injury was caused solely by Suffolk’s own negligence.

Additionally, Maccarone provided a certificate of insurance showing it had adequate coverage under two Travelers-issued policies:

  • A primary general liability policy from Travelers Property Casualty Co., and
  • A follow-form umbrella liability policy from Travelers Indemnity Insurance Co.

Importantly, Suffolk was listed as an additional insured on both policies.

Travelers Denies Responsibility

Liberty Mutual tendered the claim to Travelers on February 22, 2022, notifying them that Suffolk was an additional insured and a contractual indemnitee under Maccarone’s Travelers policies.

However, on April 13, 2022, Travelers formally denied any obligation to defend or indemnify Suffolk. Over the course of 2022 and 2024, Liberty Mutual repeatedly requested reconsideration of this denial:

  • September 27, 2024: Liberty Mutual followed up with a second request.
  • October 22, 2024: Liberty Mutual sent another letter urging Travelers to reverse its position.

To date, Travelers has not reimbursed any of the legal costs Liberty Mutual incurred in defending Suffolk.

Also Read: MS Transverse CEO Matson Transitions to Vice Chairman, Paulsson Appointed CEO

Legal Action and Settlement

Frustrated by the lack of cooperation, Liberty Mutual filed a federal lawsuit seeking a court declaration that:

  1. Suffolk qualified as an additional insured under the Travelers policies.
  2. Travelers was obligated to provide defense and indemnity coverage.
  3. Liberty Mutual should be reimbursed for expenses already incurred.

Now, with the announcement of a pending settlement between Liberty Mutual and Travelers, the insurance dispute appears to be nearing a resolution. The case has raised important questions about subcontractor insurance obligations, policyholder rights, and the proper use of additional insured provisions in construction contracts.

Key Timeline of Events

Date Event
March 12, 2020 Oscar Marin falls into elevator shaft at NYU Hospital site
February 24, 2021 Marin files personal injury lawsuit against Suffolk and Maccarone
February 22, 2022 Liberty Mutual tenders claim to Travelers
April 13, 2022 Travelers denies coverage for Suffolk
September–October 2024 Liberty Mutual sends follow-up requests for reconsideration
February 27, 2025 Liberty Mutual sues Travelers in federal court
May 28, 2025 Settlement notice filed; finalization expected within 60 days

Also Read: Sweden to Step Up Insurance Checks on Foreign Ships Because of Russia

Final Thoughts

This case underscores the critical importance of clear indemnity clauses and proper liability insurance documentation in construction projects. It also illustrates how insurance litigation between carriers, even industry giants like Liberty Mutual and Travelers, can arise from contractual interpretations.

As legal teams and insurers await the finalization of the settlement, this lawsuit could serve as a benchmark for future disputes involving additional insured provisions, especially in high-risk sectors like construction.